People are still using satellite images to do their edits

[AlanOfTheBerg]

I'm curious why you are using Cartouche to edit?

[crazycomputingdotnet]

ign-kateryna is someone that waze hired to do map editing. You can report all ign issues here:

viewtopic.php?f=8&t=12644

I had the exact same issue with that ign myself with a major highway through OKC.

[dmcconachie]

Bing is currently your only option I'm afraid.

via Tapatalk

[dmcconachie]

I was afraid of that, but given the half-assed nature of Waze it is about what I expected. Thanks for answering.

Half-assed? It's free, we're lucky to have aerials at all!

via Tapatalk

[dmcconachie]

Until such a time as waze can actually capitalise our hard work then financially speaking it has no value and so free or cheap sources are all you can expect.

I believe Israel, where the whole process started, never had an aerial to work from in the first place so it can be done. It just requires buy-in from local users.

As for basemaps, it's still possible to work without one. I had my local city working pretty well before the UK basemap was introduced. It takes time. It takes patience!

[dmcconachie]

I fear you may misunderstand me. My disparaging remarks are about Waze....not the Bing aerial photos. If there are no other free options out there, then the editor shouldn't make it look as though there are.

And how should it differentiate? It just downloads the aerial tile from Bing - if the tile is crap it has no way of knowing it.

Uhhhh......I know that. Every inch of roadway in the Japan Waze map is user-generated. Unlike your country, I believe our prospects of someday having a basemap are very poor. We also suffer from tons and tons of spurious crap and fragments on the map and from editors who make a mess out of things (half my edits are cleaning up the junk and errors put in by a guy who is area manager for about half the country). I seriously don't know why Waze even bothered opening up here; the implementation would have to improve tenfold to rise to the level of being merely farcical. As I mentioned earlier, we do it for points and the idle distraction like you would get from working a jigsaw puzzle. It is not now nor is it ever likely to be an even marginally useful map/navi app here.

Which is exactly how it used to be here. Crap aerials, "Red spaghetti" everywhere for all sorts of reasons. Clean up was a nightmare and that was before you tried to actually add anything!

Waze hasn't officially launched in Japan, yet. It's only "open" there in the same way it was in many other places before it reached a level deemed fit for launch. If you know of any free sources for a basemap then get in touch with http://www.waze.com/support and they'll be only too happy to try and arrange implementation

[dmcconachie]

Thanks for further illustrating my point about how half-assed Waze is.

1. They didn't even do the bare minimum of offering a Japanese interface for the app.

2. If Bing is my only choice, the editor shouldn't make it appear otherwise.

3. It isn't incumbent upon users to do their work by going around hunting up a basemap for them.

Any day now I expect to receive a notification from Waze giving us a schedule telling each of us what days we are expected to come clean their offices and make coffee.

You're welcome to pay for the service you clearly expect by using one of many other offerings on the market!

[dmcconachie]

Absolutely, most of us have been and still are frustrated at many aspects but there are ways to express that though. Throwing insults about the place and toys out the pram are two ways to guarantee that people focus on your delivery rather than what you have to say.

via Tapatalk

[dmcconachie]

Apologists, fanboys and inept are all words that I would take offence to and I'm sure the waze staff would too.

If anyone blindly dismisses your reasoned logic then just ignore them too. I assure you I would not. I've been well known to have rants of my own on here, on twitter and in person.

We all want to see more from waze and the best way is to get involved constructively. I've seen many discussions like this one result in someone giving up completely. I've also seen just as many get involved and become waze champions in their area.

Personally I'm feeling a little disillusioned with waze at the moment as I have done before. But having put (considerable) time and effort in I'm persevering at the moment. I believe my current experience with waze is better than what you are experiencing and that is partly down to that effort. Do I get as much as I want from waze? No, not yet. Can I rely on it for navigation in areas I've overseen? Pretty much. Outside those areas I'm skeptical for sure but with our active and growing community those areas are shrinking all the time.

I'm in this for the long term and can envision a very useful, and dominant, product. That doesn't happen overnight though and unfortunately the current marketplace seems to demand instant satisfaction. Personally I love being part of the rise of Waze!

via Tapatalk

[dmcconachie]

ok, let's not go off on a tangent from a tangent. Arguing and name-calling aside let's identify the issues and see where we as a community might be able to help, if there are any known issues or weaknesses at the moment and if there are issues we need to raise to support for their input.

Can you provide a permalink and description of an area or route that is causing a particular problem? Apologies if you have before but it's not always easy to trawl through previous posts, particularly on the phone.