Every couple of years, I stick my hand up and suggest that our ramp names could be better. That time has round again
Rationale
Why? Drivers need to have concise and accurate instructions that match the signs they see out of the window. Our current ramp naming strategy focuses too much on the names of the following roads, and cardinal directions, which often doesn’t match the signage. So, I propose something that is radically different, but hopefully more useful for drivers.
Generally
Ramp names to be short, useful and non-ambiguous.
No more “Junction to” or “Entry to”. We just want to hear “… onto A34”.
Only include cardinals if they are listed on approaching signs.
The ‘>’ character will be read out as ‘towards’, followed by the name of a city.
Entry and Exit should be considered equal for the purposes of naming, and should be named to give the most useful instruction to the driver. Junctions with numbers:
All numbered junctions should have a ramp (to give ‘exit’ instruction) with a name starting with that number, and then the name of the road it goes to (e.g. J11 to A123). Ideally without cardinals if possible.
Motorway splits should have short ‘wayfinder’ ramps so that these names don’t appear on the map.
No junction numbers on entry ramps. Junctions without numbers:
If ramps connect directly to exactly 1 other road, then they can both be left unnamed so they naturally take on the name of the next segment.
However, it might be desirable to name the ramps more simply to remove cardinals or road names. For example, “onto A1” instead of the mouthful that is “onto A1(M) (N)” or “onto A1 - Great North Road”.
If the ramp connects to a roundabout, then an unnamed segment will often give optimal instructions. However, need to be careful where routes off of the roundabout are not signed from the main road. In this case, ramp should be named to match the exit signs. Disambiguation
Where a ramp forks into two directions, then the ramp names should include cardinals (if signed) or “towards a city” based on the sign. For example: A1 to M62 has “M62 > Hull” and “M62 > Manchester”. Note: “>” is only to be used when needed, not every ramp.
Only one city from the sign is to be used, preferably the one which is listed first.
On the M25, where relevant, directions to Heathrow or Gatwick should take precedence.
If the section of ramp before the fork is particularly short, then the preceding segment can be left unnamed with the junction number written in the forked segments. This does result in longer announcements, so should be avoided if possible.
Where both directions of a road are connected to from a roundabout, then ramps can be disambiguated using “> city” instead of cardinals, as per signage.
Examples to follow. Any questions, objections or suggestions?
Note: this is just a proposal - please don’t rush out to rename all your local ramps just yet…
Here’s a restricted junction that only goes to (and from) the A659, so ramps can be unnamed. Users won’t even get an instruction to enter the A64.
Another restricted junction. Exit ramp could have been unnamed, but needs to be named “A162” so that there’s a ‘keep right’ for people turning to go north. Entry ramp is named “A64” for shorter instructions, but it doesn’t really matter either way.
Simple junction with roundabout. Exit ramps are simple “A1237”, even if driver is actually headed to a different road. Entry ramps are named “A64 > city” to provide disambiguation.
A typical roundabout junction. Exit ramps have two A roads on them as listed on the signs, even though there’s also a B road (not signed).
A numbered junction from A1 (M).
From the north, exit ramp is simply “J44 to A64” as before, and entry ramp is unnamed.
From the south, exit ramp is also “J44 to A64”, followed by a 'Keep left to A64 towards Leeds". There’s no instruction for “A64 > York”, so it could be unnamed.
The roundabout has two exits that are named “A64 > city”. Not strictly ramps, but this shows how we can improve the navigation instructions in other situations too. This may get out of hand though.
This motorway split will announce: “Exit left onto Junction 41 to M62” and then either “Keep left onto M62 towards Hull” or “Keep right onto M62 towards Manchester”.
Had the exit from A1 been unnamed, then we’d have “Exit left onto Junction 41 to M62 towards Manchester” followed by “Keep right onto Junction 41 to M62 towards Manchester”, which I think is unnecessarily wordy (like you get here).
I pretty much agree with that but I would like to suggest a differentiation for NI. We tend to get something like ‘Blaris off slip city bound’ on the traffic reports. So having our ramps named as such with the > for direction would make more sense, sort of anyway. All junctions are numbered and named so ‘Junction X whatever off slip something bound’ would be nice but I know that wouldn’t fit with the rest of the U.K.
Other than that I’m all for it as it makes more sense to the driver.
As ever, thanks for you hard work behind these proposals.
In principle, I am in complete agreement. I have 3 queries detailed below:
I agree with the naming regime for this example but feel that the ramp should actually be whatever the road type is. In this case the ramps are the A659 from beginning to end so should be type Minor Highway.
I can’t see any road numbers on these ramps
If we’re trying to keep the instructions as simple as possible would it be better for exit ramps at junctions to say “Exit left Junction 41 to M62” rather than “Exit left onto Junction 41 to M62”? That won’t work will it, because the “onto” comes automatically with the “keep left”.
Is there as well a proposal to show the Ramp Name in a more graphic version. So that it displays the sign next to or over the highway? (like you see in other nav’s or nav apps)
I agree with dropping the ‘on to’ not just from ramps but from every instruction. It’s wasted as people would rarely say it if giving directions. ‘To’ would be better for driving but the ‘arriving on to’ is wrong.
I like this. I do think when negotiating junction ramps, Waze goes into overdrive splurting out so much information, it becomes a blur. More consise the better. (Looking forward to another map raid )
I am definitely in favour of shortening and simplifying the ramp names - and that the primary aim of ramp names is to make the instructions match the signs so users can relate them to what they see out of the windscreen. I therefore particularly like
I’m not sure on leaving ramps unnamed just because there’s no instruction needed though - as the segment name is also used on traffic/hazard reports and therefore show on the “Reports Ahead” screen so users can understand where the problems are.
With a Motorway to Ramp change on both splits won’t this give “Exit left” and “Keep right”?
I’m also aware that short wayfinder segments are sometimes causing problems with gaps in the traffic bar feature, although I’m not sure how common this is - hopefully it’s an exception and therefore just deal with it as a special case.
I have a basic suggestion/request. The voice enunciating struggles with ramp numbers followed by letters, such as 781B. I suspect this could be an easy fix by using a <space> before the letter i.e. 781 B. As a level 1 I’m not able to test this.
In general - yes, I agree to the principle of trimming down clumsy directions.
I’m not keen on there being no name at all. In cases where two junctions are close together, or if visibility is poor, I like the confirmation of the instruction mimicking what’s on the road sign.
Gets my vote - the shorter the better ( shortest audible interjection to whatever I’m listening to in the car) and consistent with signage. I’m trying it out on a junction I use a lot.
I’m in favour of the proposed change. In particular, when I’m joining the M1 (N) or whatever, I want to be told to be turn onto the “em one north” not the “entry to em one north”. (Or “em one towards city” if that better reflects the signage).
if we go for that the word ‘for’ might be a much better one to use “Exit left for Coventry”, “Exit left for em one north”
I know ‘to’ is more correct for a final destination but natural English would prefer ‘for’ or ‘for the’. I doubt HQ will wish to make a differentiation change so we can have ‘to’ used if it is a destination name and ‘for (the)’ if it is another road.