Approved Edit Suggestions sometimes not applied and not visible in segment history

Is this a…:
Standard bug
Steps to reproduce this issue:
An edit suggestion of mine was approved, but the edit was not visible on the map, or in the history of the segment.

Environment where the bug occurs…:
ROW
Permalink:
https://waze.com/editor?env=row&lat=51.98006&lon=4.12401&zoomLevel=17&editSuggestions=2032e1eb-39c0-4fb1-966e-898bbbfb1150
Browser name and version:
MS Edge 141.0.3537.71 (Official build) (64-bit) (don’t know which broser was used by approving party)
Are you using scripts? Please detail which ones.:
Doesn’t apply to me as the suggestions usually go through just fine, even when the same user approves them.


1 Like

Hi @BobWithAnR,

Thanks a lot for your report!
Can you please specify what exactly is missing?
The visual instructions you suggested have been applied to the turn:

Kind regards,
Olesya

That’s because Rob entered another ES on the same turn once we discovered the first one didn’t come through :wink:

2 Likes

Thank you for the clarification. @Vestrin. The first one is indeed missing in the segment history. I have filed an internal ticket to investigate this issue.

Best regards,
Olesya

1 Like

We found another one where the same thing happened. This time by two other editors.

1 Like

Thank you for adding this example @BobWithAnR, so it’s not an isolated case then… I’ll update the internal ticket accordingly.

All the best,
Olesya

2 Likes

Hello! I just noticed that I’m having the same issue, made some visual instruction suggestions, got them approved by another editor, and they didn’t show up at all.

Here’s the link to the suggestions, all changes were approved, but the instruction suggested is empty. Both screenshots are from the linked suggestion.


I am also having the same issue. I have at least 10 examples I can provide if needed. Here’s one: https://www.waze.com/en-US/editor?zoomLevel=17&lat=35.72855453918534&lon=-78.88737469883316&editSuggestions=56a38821-ee22-4ba8-9cc4-858707304058&env=usa

The suggestion was approved by @elijahpruitt, but it doesn’t show in the edit history on the segment.

This example demonstrates that hovering over “see suggested” shows the visual the turn currently has, and not always a blank one. It’s not the same as my suggestion because I added another shield and control cities. https://www.waze.com/en-US/editor?zoomLevel=17&lat=34.919102499999994&lon=-78.02572499999998&editSuggestions=590ba934-7f99-4edf-bf12-cbd1aca99fee&env=usa&tab=feature_editor

I have experienced similar issues (on WME Production, USA) where I have submitted edit suggestions for VI.

On this segment and this segment, the VI edit suggestion I submitted shows as accepted in the history, with no changes since then.. however it does not show on the active map.

On this segment, the Road Shield Assistant script shows there is VI, however my suggestion and its later acceptance are completely missing from the history.

Thank you @AngryDragonX @h4ck3r1248 @mikejeep47 for all your examples, they’ve been added to the internal ticket for further investigation - it is still being worked on and I will let you know when there is an update.

Of course, all examples are much appreciated.

Thank you for your patience and best regards,
Olesya

1 Like