Template of topic 380525, post 1
The Problem With Some City Names
Some Australian suburb (city) names are not unique in their state. For example, there are four suburbs in NSW called Back Creek.
How Waze Currently Deals With Cities
Non-unique city names can create problems with Waze placing suburb name labels in the wrong place, as well as potentially offering a route that goes to a far-distant suburb instead of to the right street in a nearby one of the same name.
If you are editing the map in WME, and have the City layer turned on, you might see a city polygon extending somewhere off the edge of the map instead of being a nice contained region. This is known as a smudge. It can be due to mislabelling of streets or landmarks in the wrong city, or it can be due to the same city name being used for distinct suburbs.
Naming Australian Cities
The basis of the city name is the official name of the suburb or locality, without applying any abbreviations.
Template of topic 380209, post 14
Note that “St” (for “Saint”) in a suburb name is part of the legal name (except for Mount Saint Thomas in NSW). It should not be expanded to “Saint”, but it should be shown as “St.” to get correct pronunciation.
Whether the city name is derived from a suburb, locality, division or district, it should be spelled in the conventional way for proper nouns (with initial capitals). Exceptions:
- All capitals for initialisms - i.e. MP Creek, HMAS Cerberus, OB Flat, Brownlow KI, Kingston SE
- The first letter after “O’” is capitalized - e.g. O’Connell, O’Malley, Tam O’Shanter
The WME will not allow normal editors to change the capitalisation of city names once they are in place. If you discover a city name that is wrongly capitalised, contact your country manager to get it fixed.
The city name may then need modification to make it unique within the state. Each “City” with a unique name (within a state) must be named in the following way:
<City>Examples are:- Parramatta
- Newport Beach
- Brighton-Le-Sands
If the city name is not unique within the state it should be named in the following way:
<City> <Id>as shown in the list of Australian Duplicate Cities Note: <Id> is the PSMA ID, not the postcode. Examples are:- Mount Pleasant 4521
- Mount Pleasant 4720
Using these rules makes the suburb unique and removes some of the problems outlined above. If a suburb or part of a suburb is known by a different local name, this can be placed as an Alternative name for that street/landmark.
If you want to know whether a suburb name is unique, see Australian Duplicate Cities.
“The highlighted road is too far…” message
When adding a city name to a segment you will at times receive a The highlighted road is too far… from the city it was added to. message when trying to save in WME
The current version of WME prevents the naming of a street or landmark that is considered ‘too far’ away from an established City (it’s not clear how far ‘too far’ is). This is a good thing, as it prevents trans-state suburbs and thus prevents “Smudged Cities”. The problem with this is that WME might not allow you to name widely separated parts of a new suburb. The solution to this is to name and save major roads or highways first, and then name and save the roads that join to these streets so that the suburb is extended gradually instead of trying to label the edges of a suburb first.
A good indication that you may be ‘too far’ away from the existing suburb is that the suburb name doesn’t automatically appear in WME when naming a street as a pop-up option when you type the first couple of letters of the name of the suburb in the “City” field.