Editing collaboration

Hello,

I’m (relatively) new here but I’ve become rather addicted to map editing and recently got area manager for most of Dublin and north Wicklow.

Anyway, I notice several other map editors (arthurohara, lleyden, zzemca, among others (I’m sure I’m forgetting several)) who are very active around the same areas as me and I propose that we all cooperate where possible and use this forum to discuss best practices for how best to edit certain things (such as complicated junctions, new territory and so on). I’ve changed a couple of junctions in some places so that the client will hopefully give clearer navigation instructions, but I notice that others sometimes like to arrange them a little differently.

I suggest a new forum post each time a tricky editing problem comes up.

If I get any positive feedback to this post, then I’ll start doing just that.

David Graham \ davidg666

Positive feedback +1

Sorry, havn’t been in for a while but am all in favour of cooperation - been ploughing a lone furrow for a too long now (not sure if ploughing a furrow is the right metaphor for editing in Dublin though).

Hi David,

I would be in favour of your proposal and willing to be open, frank and forthcoming about any editing I conduct and happy to discuss difficult problems arising. I may not be able to answer promptly because the earning job does take precedence, naturally in light of the fiscal fiasco our country is presently afflicted by.

I think it is a great idea for the general betterment of Waze in Ireland. Perhaps we could re-title this post as “Editing Collaboration Ireland”.

I would encourage everyone to openly take part, especially those with the most experience and be prepared to move forward in a spirit of co-operation.

I would agree that a new forum post be made in respect of each editing problem arising.

Like yourself I’m relatively new and have a lot of learning to do. Its an ongoing process, all about practice. There will be mistakes but, its only by mistakes we learn. I don’t like the old editor and find it a little unwieldy. The sooner additional functions are added to the new one the better. There are other issues that cause frustration. The most frustrating one for me is locked road segments.

Good luck,

Arthur.

Hey guys! Thought I’d say hi. Thanks for starting the thread David.

Hopefully waze is gonna get so good in Ireland that we actually will feel we’re getting benefit from all time we’re putting into it.

The other day waze showed me a short cut in Dun Laoghaire that actually saved me about two minutes.

Hey all,

Today I’ve done most Editing with Waze so far. Will see if I didn’t mess up someone’s work :roll:
Traveled today to Monaghan and Scotstown, so as a reminder for myself I drew roads around the Scotstown together with Landmarks of objects where I was at.

I am not feeling comfortable enough adding names or deciding where roads starts and ends as I can’t understand by what criteria they are marked :? As an example, you can see in Scotstown, they have a road called “Bog road”. Surprisingly it goes in pretty much all directions from and to town (East, South, West…) I believe this is mistake in Google map, but frankly, not the first time I see roads going in different directions (more than Two) with same name.

So, to sum up what I mean by my post:
Is it OK that I draw the roads with out names? Or little effort is worse than none, because someone else will have trouble editing my roads? :roll:

Thanks
P.S. I’m not an Irish… I’m Lithuanian

Hi Agamicox,

Just a quick reply on one thing you mentioned:

Even though it’s inconvenient, we must not use Google Maps (or similar) to get the names of roads in the Waze map - we can only use publicly-known sources. So it’s OK to use Google Street View to look at road signs that are there in the physical world, but we can’t legally copy Google’s road name data. This is possibly a good thing from one point of view, because I notice it’s often incorrect anyway.

++David \ davidg666

Thanks. That means I won’t use Google Map road names.

Hi all,

Literally brand new to Waze and very excited! I’m based in Kildare but the job takes me all over!

I’ve watched the videos and edited (very small edits, no road names etc just yet) some of the smaller roads in my area.

For the moment I am right in saying that just driving around with Waze running is a help to all, naturally I’d prefer this until I’m properly comfortable editing and helping out!

Looking forward to being a part of something that will be a help to all!

Dave

Hi Davercade,

Greetings! In so far as I’m concerned new Editors like yourself are very welcome!

I strongly feel that we are doing something for the “Common Good” out there on the road.

We all had to start somewhere and make mistakes, otherwise we would never learn.

Without sounding in any way presumptuous, I will be delighted to be of assistance and collaborate with you. Don’t hesitate to get in touch.

Here are a few links that will be of assistance:-

  1. Ordnance Survey Ireland: http://maps.osi.ie/publicviewer/#V1,525009,819937,0,10

  2. S.I. No. 53/2012 — Roads Act 1993 (Classification of National Roads) Order 2012: http://www.irishstatutebook.ie/2012/en/si/0053.html

  3. S.I. No. 54/2012 — Roads Act 1993 (Classification of Regional Roads) Order 2012: http://www.irishstatutebook.ie/2012/en/si/0054.html

Safe motoring assisted by http://www.waze.com

Sincerely,

Arthur.
Sat 29 Sep 2012 1231 GMT Daylight Time Wk. 39.

I posted this elsewhere on the forum, but thought it worthwhile to reiterate here, as I see a lot of new editors in the Munster area recently.
Arthur’s links above are vital to check, as is:

Hey folks,

Just wanted to pop in and say “Hi!”

I’m relatively new to Waze but have been an OSM contributor for a while. I’m based in Cork and drive for work so I’ll do what I can to add to the extent of the map in and around.

I don’t tend to hang around in Forums that much so forgive me if I don’t seem to be as active as I should, just trust me that I’m doing my thing on the road and in the editor :slight_smile:

I hope to get to know a few of you over the coming weeks and months.

See ye later,

Diarmuid.

Hi,

I don’t know how to drop in a link to an Edition place… maybe u can find it by ID…
I’ve paved and now created one road between N81 and Ballymore City. It is L2025. I’ve marked it as Primary Road and Level 0… although roads around it are marked with Minor Highway and Level 4 or 1… Sorry If i made something wrong. U are more than welcome to edit it as it should be.

Length: 2513 meters
Updated: today by Agamicox(1)
Created: yesterday by Agamicox(1)
ID: 200145496

Do you mean this segment here?

https://world.waze.com/editor/?zoom=3&lat=53.13208&lon=-6.59345&layers=BFTFFTTTTFTTFTTTTTFTTTTFT&segments=200145496

To make a link to a selected segment or area on the map, click on the “Permalink” button near the bottom-right of the editor window, and then copy the URL from the address bar of your browser.

Generally, only R-roads (for example R755, R148 and so on) should be of type “minor highway”. All lesser roads should be of type “street” or “primary street”, and “primary street” should only be used for roads that are wide enough for two cars to pass without having to slow down, and that have a significant volume of traffic.

As for levels: all roads should have level zero, except where they cross without touching (such as a motorway bridge). In this case, higher-up roads should have a higher level than the roads they cross. In the simple case where a smaller road crosses a motorway, the motorway would have level 0 and the smaller road would have level 1 - or level -1 if it passes underneath the motorway.

The road levels have no effect on routing, and the only reason for having different road levels is so that they can be drawn on the client the right way, with higher roads above lower roads. The current version of the client doesn’t do this properly, but older versions did do this, and hopefully the client will do it properly again. Apart from this, the level doesn’t matter much at all, so just leave it at zero for almost all roads.

Good work for mapping a road where there are almost no aerial images!

++David \ davidg666

How to disallow U turns on Dual-Carriageways at places where another road crosses it.

I had a scenario on Monday where I was navigating and expected Waze to direct me from Segment 1 (N6 W) to Segment 6 (R339).
It didn’t - it identified a quicker route going from Segment 1 to Segment 5 (my final destination was 25 km away). Unfortunately, this is an illegal U turn, which is not allowed at this junction.

In this example it is difficult to configure this in the editor, as we still need to allow right turns onto the dual carriageway from the R339.

Any suggestions on this?

Stopping U-turns in places where two split roads meet is quite hard, however I do have two ideas:

  1. Possibly R339 should not be split here - there’s no central median, and I’m not sure if it meets the usual criteria for splitting roads (I think this is described in the wiki somewhere), however even if R339 wasn’t split, then the same kind of illegal U-turn could still be issued by Waze, so this idea isn’t all that much help, so on to the next idea:

  2. I’d recommend a mapcat bowtie for this junction, whether or not R339 is split. I think this may be documented in the wiki, but it basically entails having all roads in the junction converge in a single junction node. This then allows U-turns to be disabled for any direction at all. It looks a bit weird in the editor, but looks fairly OK on the client. If you want me to go into greater detail about how to make a mapcat bowtie, say so and I’ll describe it in more detail.

(the mapcat bowtie is so called because the editor who first ‘invented’ it is called mapcat, and it looks a little like a bowtie when it’s made. We don’t have very many mapcat bowties in Ireland, but they are quite widely used around the world).

Hope this helps,

++David \ davidg666

Thanks David,
I did the mapcat bowtie, but now when I am approaching the junction, but going straight through, the client is telling me to turn right and left.
The instruction to turn right is the segment which brings me to the centre of the bowtie, while the left turn is the segment coming out of the centre.
In reality, they are more like 45 degree turns rather than a right followed by left.
Is there any way around this - the previous method is preferable to this.
Thanks,
John

Hi John,

Have you taken the bowtie away again? I don’t see it in the editor at the N6/R339 intersection (or are you talking about a different intersection?)

Anyway, the mapcat bowtie does usually work, but it needs very shallow angles so that (to the client) it just looks like a wiggle in the road, and straight-through drivers aren’t given any instructions, and turning drivers just get one instruction.

Here’s one I made a while ago (not quite the same situation, since it’s just a T-junction, so it probably isn’t really necessary here):

https://world.waze.com/editor/?zoom=5&lat=53.34263&lon=-6.31702&layers=BFTFFTTTTFTTFTTTTTFTTTTFT&segments=151189505

…this one works fine: it gives the correct directions for all directions of travel. I think the trick is to keep all the angles quite shallow, so that it doesn’t look strange on the phone, and so that it gives the right directions. You can do this by stretching it out so that each approach road starts to bend towards the centre of the junction maybe 100m or so before the junction.

++David \ davidg666

Thanks David - Apologies for the late reply!
Yes - another editor had removed my bowtie and reverted back to the standard layout. In fairness to them, my original edit was giving a turn right/turn left instructions when going straight ahead so they were correct to make the change.
I’ve updated it again so hopefully it will work now.
Thanks,
John

Hi John,

Aha. It might be worth your while dropping a message to the other editor if you’re both editing the same junction in different ways, so you can both get on the same page. I’ve done that a few times and it’s helped very quickly.

Anyway, about the turn right/left instructions in a mapcat bowtie when going straight ahead: I find if the bends in roads leading into the bowtie are slight enough (and happen far enough away from the centre of the bowtie) then they appear to the client as nearly straight enough to not get any instructions when going straight (as you’d expect) and they also appear normal enough on the client screen not to make some other editor want to change them to “fix” them.

It might be worth leaving a note on the map next to the junction to explain to other editors the reason for setting up the junction the way it is. The only practical way to do this for now is to use a short railway segment, because this will be visible in the editor but won’t ever be shown on the client. (there are occasional rumblings of some kind of map annotation feature coming to the editor, but it’s not here yet).

++David \ davidg666