I been watching the discussion in the NY subforum on road classification and matching the road types to the functional class, where the following corrolation was proposed.
I’m wondering how to correlate to the classes I see from the Maryland State Highway Adminstration, which seem to be:
Interstate
Frwy Expwy
OPA
Minor Art
Major Coll
Coll
Minor Coll
Local
I guess I’m wondering what is marked as Principal Arterial (Expwy) and whether that would match with Frwy Expwy here. Here the Frwy Expwy roads are limited access and are currently typed as freeways. Examples are MD-100 and MD-32. Are these the types of roads that others find marked Principal Arterial (Expwy) and mark as major highways? Are there any freeways that are not Interstates when you mark Principal Arterial (Expwy) as major highways?
While a road in given it’s Functional Classification by the states, they have to set those types based on Federal Functional Classification Definitions from the US DOT…
Each state must define roads into one of the following categories:
URBAN
Principal Arterial - Interstate
Principal Arterial - Other Expressway
Principal Arterial - Other
Minor Arterial
Collector
Local
RURAL
Principal Arterial - Interstate
Principal Arterial - Other Expressway
Principal Arterial - Other
Minor Arterial
Major Collector
Minor Collector
Local
The US DOT definitions intentionally overlap to provide flexibility, so do the Waze Road Type Definitions…
Starting simply, a limited access road in Waze is defined to fall into either “Freeway” or “Major Highway”, match that up with the US DOT Definitions and you get “Primary Arterial - Interstate” and “Primary Arterial - Other Expressway”. Two Waze types, two Functional Classifications, pretty easy match.
As for Maryland: MD = US DOT = Waze
Interstate = Primary Arterial - Interstate = Freeway
Frwy Expwy = Primary Arterial - Other Expressway = Major Highway
OPA = Principal Arterial - Other = Minor Highway
Minor Art = Minor Arterial = This is the gray area I mentioned in my earlier post, right now I’m tracing them back to Urban areas & matching that type.
Major Coll = Major Collector (Rural) = Primary
Coll = Collector (Urban) = Primary
Minor Coll = Minor Collector (Rural) = Primary
Local = Local = Street
I considered that, but decided against it for a few reasons…
In CT they are few and far between
Most of the ones that do exist, start in an urbanized area as a regular Collector, cross into a rural area & change designation to a Minor Collector. This would leave a road that seemingly randomly changes type.
It’s still a collector, something that local streets feed to & would have higher traffic priority over local cross streets (i.e. timed traffic lights, fewer stop signs, etc)
I’m in favor of using the functional classifications as a significant factor in road type decisions and have been giving much thought to your matches. I however cannot bring myself to adopt it. The most basic issue is that is not what has been done here. Non-interstate limited access highways have been typed as freeways here. Although, the wiki now states that that major highways “Can have stoplights or freeway style interchanges.” I hadn’t taken that to mean we should be typing roads that exclusively use freeway style interchanges as either freeways or major highways, but rather that roads with both are likely major highways. As most Frwy Expwy roads here fully meet the Freeway definition that is what they have been typed. In the few instances where I have seen parts of limited access highways classed as major highways around here, someone has always changed them to freeway (sometimes by waze staff like here). I also have been basically applying the rule that if I am in doubt between two types use the higher type. My reasoning being that its better for roads to be included in the routing decisions than not.
If I was starting from scratch, I would really like to use your correlations because they are straightforward. As it is we have no good match for Major Highway. But I can’t see myself changing the non-interstate freeways to major highways around here at this point.
I’ve been using the above with success in the upper part of my county so far, but I haven’t touched anything classified as a “Freeway” (yet). Just getting the minor hwy and primary streets is a big deal and will hopefully help routing. Based on the DOT classes I did change a couple of small stretches of road from major to minor though as they were in between sections of minor highways and just got divided, but with excessive stop lights and only appearing for a few miles those stretches were hardly a major highway.
I’ve been adjusting roads according to the FHCS maps(1) for Richmond, VA; my mapping system was a little bit different though.
Interstate = Freeway
Principal Arterial (Expwy) = Freeway
Principal Arterial (Other) = Maj Hwy
Minior Arterial = Minor Hwy
Collector = Primary
Local = Street
There’s only about 5 roads in the area marked as Principal Arterial (Expwy) type so I figured I should merge them into one of the other categories rather than use an entire category for a handful of roads. Since they are Interstate type roads (no at grade junctions, highest speed limits) I bumped them up to the freeway category. Richmond, VA in Waze
It also compares favorably with how google classifies roads for what that’s worth. Richmond, VA in GMaps
This is what I want to do, but there are too many two-lane highways around here classed as OPA (Other Principal Arterial), that really don’t meet any of the expectations for a major highway.