Long-distance routing

Some of the routes below is not fixed yet, please assist if you are in the area, and please add more towns that need fixing.

2016-01-20 - Long distance routing seem to work better to Western/Eastern Cape since changing routes through small town to be the same as the incoming e.g. Major highway.
It seems for longer distances Waze optimizes by only looking at the Highways.
Links:
https://www.waze.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=142294#p1119405
https://www.waze.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=122&t=135581
RodNav: Searching for “routing road types” I found this in a French posting at
https://world.waze.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=34&t=23408&p=248134&hilit=routing+road+types#p248120

2015-04-11 - Problem George[hide]Going down from JHB to George / Knysna in December 2014 and now in April 2015 it seems Waze struggles with long distance routing.

Found a old thread https://www.waze.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=62&t=19793 discussing route types.

The problem seems to be Major highways (N12) changing to Primary streets through small town’s breaking the routing. (Waze filter’s routes for Highways)

Found this forum post explaining some of the routing.
https://wiki.waze.com/wiki/User:Nhanway/Continuity_in_Road_Types

I propose we make all the roads through a small town Major Highways, to enable proper routing.

Only down side i see is person in the town having “Avoid Highways” but it does not seem likely.[/hide]
2015-04-22 - Looks better. e.g. Roodepoort -> VictoriaBay
Now Waze is giving the N12 as a possible route, now looking at highways in the Eastern Cape area that passes through towns.

Roodepoort -> Cape St Francis

  • 2015-10-07 This gives the option of 3 routes now. N6, N10, R57

Howic(KZN) -> Neslpruit

  • 2015-10-07 This also give 3 options now, N3(All the way), N3/N11, R33

I’ve seen the same issue and have experimented with the road types to solve it but at this stage the results are inconclusive. My issue is Howick to Nelspruit. After changing a bunch to minor highway through towns (ans waiting for a tile update) the same incorrect route was suggested. Unless there is another update to the routing server that I do not know about that has to happen I’m at a bit of a loss.

I suggest you make the changes and see if there is any improvement and report back here.

Edit: to be clear, the change to a major highway should only be if the road outside of town is one already. No sense having a minor coming in then suddenly change to a major just for the bit in town.

[hide]Done Beaufortwes (N12) - Majore Highway through town.
https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=22.58333&lat=-32.35000&layers=421&zoom=3[/hide]

[hide]De Rust
https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=22.53576&lat=-33.49039&layers=421&zoom=4&segments=249289727[/hide]

[hide]Oudtshoorn -> Majore highway.
Waiting for unlock to L3
https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=22.20271&lat=-33.59419&layers=421&zoom=3&segments=163994526,163995634,164176126,164176127,164176387,164883475,164883592,164883763,251527040,164176503,164885869,164883395,165657288,164264189,251527788,251527784,251527781,251527735,164176593,166165650,164176379,166163352,272648580,251543465,198481471,251545324,251545089,251545087

2015-04-15 - Unlocked
https://www.waze.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=327&t=137383&p=1084112#p1084112

Missed small piece that still needs updating.
https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=22.21310&lat=-33.59451&layers=421&zoom=6&segments=164264231

2014-04-15 Done[/hide]

[hide]The section of road through Kareedow in Eastern Cape needs to be changed to Major highway.

https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=24.29041&lat=-33.95028&layers=421&zoom=4&segments=166038526,208514034,208514035,208514049,208514053,208514059,208514060,208514063,208514064

2014-04-15 log request for help to change road type.
https://www.waze.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=327&t=137439&p=1084180#p1084180[/hide]

[hide]I think this was causing the routing prob

https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=24.53090&lat=-32.24985&layers=421&zoom=6&segments=191508555,191508556,247324345,252724462,252724499,252724500,252724595,252724596,264115327,264115328,162619652,162619653,162619273,162619272,189127972,191386529,191387206,191508078,191508077,191508059,191508318,191508317,191386530,189128035,162619025,191506797,191506796,191510110,191510118,84255533,191510096,191510095,147567288,84093035,84093034,186806746,191512500,186806745

I think this was causing the routing problems here in Aberdeen (South of Graaff-Reinette)
https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=24.05720&lat=-32.47399&layers=421&zoom=2[/hide]

[hide]Someone with access, please change this segment in Venterstad to Major Highway.

https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=25.80076&lat=-30.77940&layers=421&zoom=5&segments=214206830,214206836,214206837[/hide]

[hide]Need some one with access to change the section below to “Major Highway”

https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=25.82428&lat=-31.29271&layers=421&zoom=5&segments=146635929,214120738,214120739,214121289,214121294,214121295,214121315,214121316,214121922,266313555,266313572,266313573,163883462[/hide]

[hide]Need some one with access to change the section below to “Major Highway”

https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=26.36265&lat=-31.39673&layers=421&zoom=4&segments=163881091,163881092,163880791,119083520,207835946,207835944,100748949[/hide]

[hide]This seems to be a big change.
5 Major roads entering and leaving the Town.

Need to change the routes connecting them in the town to “Major Highway”

https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=27.39664&lat=-32.88188&layers=421&zoom=2&segments=162198425[/hide]

Only one section.
Debatable if we should change it to “Major Highway”

https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=27.92468&lat=-32.95107&layers=421&zoom=4&segments=61051413,162200674,165308024,165307412,165307721,165307411,165307612,165307611,165307610,165307722,165307723,165307724,162200680,162200683,162200682,162200681,165308025

Checked 2016-01-20 - Looks fine now. fixed by elphix.

[hide]Section in town need to be changed to “Major Highway”

https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=28.15005&lat=-32.33388&layers=421&zoom=3&segments=162572408,162572993,162573093,189350749,257413709,257413711,266576908,266576911[/hide]

Section through Burgersdorp need to change to “Major Highway”
2015-10-07 Still a problem.
2016-01-20 Sill needs fixing.
2016-02-20 Posted link in “Unlock Requests” asking for someone to fix. https://www.waze.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=62&t=136807&start=10#p1089982

https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=26.33530&lat=-30.99678&layers=421&zoom=3&segments=165173909,165174366,165175185,165175228,165175802,165175843,165175844,165173865,165174545,165174544,165173910,165174688,165174969,165174968,266575092,266575091

[hide]Section through Aliwal North, needs to be changed to “Major Highway”

https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=26.71517&lat=-30.69696&layers=421&zoom=3&segments=146838776,146839366,147400707,163095269,163096368,163096369,163097002,163097057,163097058,163099474,163099475,163100540,163100686,247331045,163095383,163099271,163099270,145970088,163099595,163099596,163097236,163097235,272137874,272137909,272137908,163084423,163084768,163084868,163096695[/hide]

[hide]Main road’s through Mthata, must be changed to “Major Highway”
2015-10-07 R61 through town still a issue
2016-02-20 Seem to be fixed by elphix, now all Major Highway’s connected.

https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=28.77920&lat=-31.59146&layers=421&zoom=1&segments=162355534,162355720,162356390,162364024,162368999,162369074,162369075,238687259,239104132,239104136,239104137,239104167,239104168,267922407,267922633,267922634,162369232,162355982,162356305,162356304,162351873,162355989,162355988,162355435,162369231,238686990,188890052,249250503,162366962,162366573,249757381,251217288,251217289,251217287,162364217,251217292,188889879,251217297,188889865,251217657,238687188,238687187,162367982,162367059,238687715,162367639,162367719,162367720,162356592,162356389,162355796,162355726,162355614[/hide]

[hide]Section through Adelaid need to be changed to “Majore Highway”

https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=26.29668&lat=-32.71180&layers=421&zoom=3&segments=164225492,164225654,164225655,164225389,164225388,163882431,164224682,163882458,163882459,163882376,164224755,164227304,164227303,164227235,164226617,164226616,164225237[/hide]

[hide]Section through town need to be changed to “Major Highway”
2015-10-07 Still a problem
2016-02-20 Fixed. Thank elphix.

https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=26.89143&lat=-31.90440&layers=421&zoom=2&segments=162659640,165054227,165054226,162629185,184444583,184444582,184444587,184444586,184444585,184444584,152829765,165055850,184444785,184444784,165055619,267796726,267796725,165055620[/hide]

[hide]In Vereniging, a lot of “Major Highways” get together.
They are not connected as “Major Highways”

2015-10-07 General Hertzog Rd should probably also be a “Major Highways”
2016-02-20 Fixed. Thanks elphix.

https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=27.95322&lat=-26.65149&layers=421&zoom=1[/hide]

Pieter, if I’m not mistaken most of the segments you’ve linked to are not locked higher than L3. Are you suggesting other editors do the changes because of a lack of editing rights?