I have been noticing some trouble when searching addresses where the city name in Waze is a census designated place instead of the actual city name that is used in the actual adddress.
For example, there is a UR from a Wazer who is trying to search for 612 12th Ave in Menlo Park. I created another forum comment here about it.
Waze’s database has this as being “North Fair Oaks”, not Menlo Park. 612 12th (or Twelfth) Ave doesn’t exist as far as Waze is concerned, so it resorts to Google Maps. Google Maps lists it as “612 Twelfth Avenue”, and places it on the wrong street.
So in this case – and every case like this – Waze’s own listings (HNs and Residential Places) will never be given in a search and we must submit a change to GM with the hope that someone will approve the change. Then if it is approved, we must remember to reply to the UR with the update.
Is there a reason why a city name in Waze is listed as a CDP rather than the actual name used in the actual address? This most certainly causes problems. Can these be changed in Waze?
We have this same issue where all the addresses/roads on the North side of Bakersfield were set to Oildale where the actual mailing addresses are Bakersfield. Would really like some guidance on this also.
Unfortunately, that is the current guidance in the Wiki. I agree that it causes problems. It can be changed, if the community can be swayed to change the guidance.
I have long advocated for using the the ‘postal’ city as the Waze city, because that is how people provide their address. Another option would be for Waze to add a zip/postal code field to address data.
Somewhere in Waze history, it became the standard to use physical cities as the city field regardless of ‘postal’ or common name. The addition of the alt-city presents new options but it can cause cross-over pollution to the city table. It is complex issue that will require further discussion.
I guess I need to research where the current guidance of only listing actual cities/cpd’s came from.
I’m not sure that using the “postal” city would be a good solution either. I lived in a very rural location many years ago. If the postal city is used, Waze would place the city name on the map about 25 miles further away than where it really is. Awkward.
I think use of the city name should be limited to the actual city limits, everywhere else should be no name.
Why is that awkward? Waze is navigation app; and if the area is generally known as Xyz Town, why not show that on the map? As far as I understand, Waze was never intended to be a city boundary map. There would be initial resistance to the change, but once it is explained, that Waze uses postal city to aid in address searches, most people would appreciate the change.
Alternatively, the primary city name could remain as “no name” and use alt-names for the postal city, to aid with searches. We would need to change Validator to not flag no name segments with an alt/city name. Or, Waze could solve all of this discussion, by adding a zip/postal code field.
Because the area isn’t generally known as Xyz Town. In fact, much of it is known by a different name. Having Waze write “[City Name]” across it would be very awkward.
What should the city be? If we were to go by the postal city, it would be Cayucos. Its actual postal address is 11030 Santa Rita Rd, Cayucos, CA 93430. The same is true of all addresses in a several mile radius.
“Cayucos” would be written across the map there if we add the city name to all roads that have it in their postal address.
But is that where you’d expect the “Cayucos” label to appear?
I am continuing to see more and more problems with routing to such addresses. Can we make these changes in the California editing community? If not, what shall we say to Wazers who report issues when routing to such addresses?
for the specific example cited by the OP: North Fair Oaks is a CDP for an unincorporated part of the county, which is why no one who lives in the area would use it when looking for map directions.
unfortunately as a result, it’s difficult to select an appropriate city to use in the address, since there are 3 surrounding cities (Menlo Park, Redwood City, Atherton) that border “North Fair Oaks” so any of those city names are fair game when looking for an address in North Fair Oaks.