Your help with Canadian cities update

Hi guys!

We’re doing some work to update the cities in Canada.

The following cities seem to be wrong names from the original basemap.

We’d like to remove them. The meaning is that all their segments will be no longer associated to any city.
(the city field in the editor will be empty).

Could you please let us know if any of the following is an actual Canadian city name?

Thanks!

Shirli

District of Thunder Bay
District of Kenora
District of Sudbury
Mackenzie County
District of Cochrane
Greenview No. 16, M.D. of
District of Algoma
Opportunity No. 17, M.D. of
Northern Sunrise County
Yellowhead County
I.D. No. 24 Wood Buffalo
Clear Hills County
Clearwater County
Big Lakes, M.D. of
Cypress County
Northern Lights No. 22, M.D. of
District of Nipissing
District of Rainy River
Lesser Slave River No. 124, M.D. of
Lac La Biche County
Woodlands County
Forty Mile No. 8, County of
District of Timiskaming
Athabasca No. 12, County of
Grande Prairie No. 1, County of
Saddle Hills County
Vermilion River No. 24, County of
Bonnyville No. 87, M.D. of
Newell No. 4, County of
Vulcan County
Rocky View County
Wheatland County
Willow Creek No. 26, M.D. of
Wainwright No. 61, M.D. of
Red Deer County
Wetaskiwin No. 10, County of
St. Paul No. 19, County of
Flagstaff County
Beaver County
Stettler No. 6, County of
Warner No. 5, County of
Provost No. 52, M.D. of
Taber, M.D. of
Mountain View County
Camrose County
Lac Ste. Anne County
Kneehill County
Paintearth No. 18, County of
Cardston County
Kananaskis I.D.
Foothills No. 31, M.D. of
Minburn No 27, County of
Westlock County
Brazeau County
Two Hills No. 21, County of
Lacombe County
Smoky Lake County
Birch Hills County
Leduc County
Parkland County
Ponoka County
Lethbridge, County of
Smoky River No. 130, M.D. of
Pincher Creek No. 9, M.D. of
Lamont County
District of Parry Sound
Barrhead No. 11, County of
Bighorn No. 8, M.D. of
I.D. No. 12 Jasper Park
Starland County
Sturgeon County
Ranchland No. 66, M.D. of
I.D. No. 9 Banff
Thorhild No. 7, County of
Fairview No. 136, M.D. of
Strathcona County
Acadia No. 34, M.D. of
Peace No. 135, M.D. of
Spirit River No. 133, M.D. of
District of Manitoulin
I.D. No. 4 Waterton
I.D. No. 13 Elk Island

Hi shirlig,

I noticed a bunch of those from around Alberta.

Some of these areas (e.g. ID 9 Banff) relate to an area outside the township limits, but inside the “Improvement District” – are you wanting to do away with county declarations (for rural areas) and such?

Also, I wonder about the repercussions of eliminating the city name – will we have errors about streets being elsewhere (and too far away)?

Since we don’t have province definitions available, it seems like this might be premature…

Any chance these could be broken down by province/territory (so that I can forward to friends/contacts in those areas)?

A good number of these are in southern alberta, but, like doktor, i’m left wondering if we are removing all the county designations then?

Most of these are municipal districts that arise from another city, but is a larger geographical area around that city, for example:

Lethbridge, County of
This contains the city of Lethbridge, AB, but also many other locations, the towns of Coalhurst, Coaldale, Picture Butte, Nobleford, Barons, and probably a dozen smaller communities such as Chin, Diamond City, Fairview, Iron Springs, Shaughnessy, Monarch and Turin. It also covers hundreds of km of land outside of those towns and the city of Lethbridge.

For navigation I’m not sure it really means one hill of beans, as each of the places inside would have its own town names, unless, as doktor fears, there is a check at the street level about too many places with the same street name existing.

If we are removing these types of designations, it seems to me that these are all OK to do so within ALBERTA as they all follow the same pattern of being a municipal district.

This gives a better, more accurate description of these entities:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_municipal_districts_in_Alberta

Acadia No. 34, M.D. of
Athabasca No. 12, County of
Barrhead No. 11, County of
Beaver County
Bighorn No. 8, M.D. of
Big Lakes, M.D. of
Birch Hills County
Bonnyville No. 87, M.D. of
Brazeau County
Camrose County
Cardston County
Clear Hills County
Clearwater County
Cypress County
Fairview No. 136, M.D. of
Flagstaff County
Foothills No. 31, M.D. of
Forty Mile No. 8, County of
Grande Prairie No. 1, County of
Greenview No. 16, M.D. of
Kneehill County
Lac La Biche County
Lac Ste. Anne County
Lacombe County
Lamont County
Leduc County
Lesser Slave River No. 124, M.D. of
Lethbridge, County of
Minburn No 27, County of
Mountain View County
Newell No. 4, County of
Northern Lights No. 22, M.D. of
Northern Sunrise County
Opportunity No. 17, M.D. of
Paintearth No. 18, County of
Parkland County
Peace No. 135, M.D. of
Pincher Creek No. 9, M.D. of
Ponoka County
Provost No. 52, M.D. of
Ranchland No. 66, M.D. of
Red Deer County
Rocky View County
Saddle Hills County
Smoky Lake County
Smoky River No. 130, M.D. of
Spirit River No. 133, M.D. of
St. Paul No. 19, County of
Starland County
Stettler No. 6, County of
Sturgeon County
Taber, M.D. of
Thorhild No. 7, County of
Two Hills No. 21, County of
Vermilion River No. 24, County of
Vulcan County
Warner No. 5, County of
Westlock County
Wetaskiwin No. 10, County of
Wheatland County
Willow Creek No. 26, M.D. of
Woodlands County
Yellowhead County

Further, Alberta is also home to Improvement Districts which are on your list. Again in terms of navigation purposes, I really don’t feel these are important to be designated on the map, unless there is a street level control check. These mostly are areas surrounding parks, both national and provicincial.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_communities_in_Alberta#Improvement_districts

From your post, these would include:

I.D. No. 24 Wood Buffalo
Kananaskis I.D.
I.D. No. 12 Jasper Park
I.D. No. 9 Banff
I.D. No. 4 Waterton
I.D. No. 13 Elk Island

I believe that leaves you with only the "District of … " entries on your list to categorize/sort out. I cannot speak to most of those as they are outside of Alberta.

District of Thunder Bay
District of Kenora
District of Sudbury
District of Cochrane
District of Algoma
District of Nipissing
District of Rainy River
District of Timiskaming

these are actual places.

Also, can you remove “Unknown” from the map completely.

We call districts “rural municipalities” in Manitoba. The basemap included the districts, but no RMs were imported from what I’ve seen. I’ve noticed other editors adding them. I don’t see any harm in leavingall of these districts, improvement areas or RMs, even if they aren’t a city. This of course is assuming that these are not causing any headaches for Waze.
James

How about fixing these problems.

Hey guys,
Let me reply to some of your questions.

We’ve eliminated the “Unknown” city last week. It might take a while to trinkle down to the live map / client map, but the editor should no longer be showing this at all. Please let us know if you notice otherwise… Alternatively if this removal causes editing problems, please let us know as well.

That should not occur. If it does please let us know and we will fix.

There are no county declarations support in waze, per say. All information regarding these counties/districts/regions is retained, we are only changing their classification to “non-cities” and removing all direct street references to them.

This change is part of a greater plan to enable provinces support in Canada. Going forward with this will considerably advance us towards that goal.

They are all actual places, question is are they a town/city or just a region? To be more accurate, should any of these appear in a standard address line, in the slot where one specifies the town/city?

I’m so glad to hear province support is being actively worked on. Hope the list of Alberta ones helps out! :slight_smile:

If we are making such a change, please revise and delete the following around Winnipeg:
RM of Rockwood
RM of Rosser
RM of Headingley
RM of Tache
RM of Ritchot
RM of Springfield
RM of Ruvercrest
RM of Brokenhead
RM of Staint Clements
RM of Staint Andrews

Please note, all these RMs around Winnipeg are very crudly done and in no way reflect the actual size of the RMs.

Going to PM the users who have been adding these RMs in the past few months to stop.
Thanks,
James

Well, that’s an interesting question.

It is unlikely that any of the Alberta ones would show up on an address line – but something would. And the county name is a lot more descriptive than not having a city declared…

For example, the “Leduc County” one would likely have either Leduc, Nisku, Beaumont or any of the other list of communities / localities found here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leduc_County,_Alberta#Communities_and_localities – but does it really make sense to go and find the limits for each of these places just to have the “City” field not say “County”?

The ‘something’ that would appear would be a box number, I’ve never understood why the county/RM/ID was never listed when mentioning an address of someone outside of a town/city. I’m also worried about potential navigational issues arising from doing this. There is sure to be duplicate streets names in different country/RM/IDs/Districts, which could cause problems if the duplicate streets are in the same province in different country/RM/ID/District.

While were on the topic of being out in the boonies, is there any way that Waze could look into modifying the ‘dirt road/4x4 segment’ type to something like ‘unpaved road’? Currently there are no options for gravel roads so we are being forced to group gravel roads into the dirt road segment type when Waze is trying to route people off highways onto gravel roads unnecessary.
Thanks,
James

That’s not necessarily true when we’re talking about a street address (as opposed to mailing).

19250 Township Rd 440, Edberg, AB should be at the “A” point here: http://goo.gl/maps/FGvwf

Despite the fact that it’s WELL outside of the Township of Edberg (point “B” on the same map).

According to the notes from Meetup 2013 ( https://www.waze.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=129&t=42406 ):

Hi guys,

Thanks for your help!
We’re going to remove the cities we mentioned.
We do keep a backup so if something goes unexpectedly wrong - we can restore it.

I will post a message to inform you when the process is done.

Thanks!

Shirli

Process done.
Pelase let us know if you encounter any issue.

Thanks!
Shirli

Thanks for that post doctorkb, didn’t see that.
James

Thanks!

Is there a way to fix multiple city names for one city?

For example, in my attached screenie, you’ll see 2 names for Lethbridge, but there are actually 3 lurking around.

Lethbridge, AB
Lethbridge, Canada
Lethbridge, AB, Canada