Ok, this ain’t right: Routing through the GO Train parking lot
All the Waze materials I’ve read on parking lot roads indicates that Waze is designed to assign sufficient penalty to parking lot roads such that it prevents routing through a parking lot. Yet, the above example has me getting to the arena via the GO train parking lot???
I checked the local streets, nothing is disconnected, no turn restrictions, no time restrictions.
It seems like Waze must be only assigning one parking lot penalty, even though the route crosses a regular street (at Henry St). I wonder if this has always been the way the routing works, or whether this has changed recently?
I found this recent thread that has the same issue and a proposed work-around, which would certainly work (if I introduced a 10 metre street segment where the GO PLR meets Henry street and got it locked to L5), but is this a recommended approach?
Has anyone got any other references for the same problem?
Thanks,
Roy.
Indeed strange behaviour.
I don’t think it is related to the fact that the navigation is commencing on a PLR, as even if I start it on the nearby Byron St S it gives the same shortcut.
Let me escalate this to the Dev Team.
HM.
The Niagara area has a similar issue with parking lot roads, this one isn’t even accessible from the road because the road is a fire lane and chained off.
https://www.waze.com/livemap?zoom=17&lat=43.15207&lon=-79.16523&from_lat=43.16051&from_lon=-79.16288&to_lat=43.15207&to_lon=-79.16523
If it’s a fire lane and chained off, it should be drawn on Waze as separate, disconnected roads AFAIK.
I just deleted the parking lot road as it did nothing to assist with navigation and instead just hindered it.
I found another local issue of the same thing, routing through a parking lot
https://www.waze.com/livemap?zoom=15&lat=43.18102&lon=-79.47937&from_lat=43.18651&from_lon=-79.47691&to_lat=43.18102&to_lon=-79.47937
I don’t see this example as the same issue (unless I missed something). This route enters the parking lot and never uses or crosses another street segment. Maybe you expected it to go to the closest street segment before entering the parking lot, but that’s not how Waze is designed to work.
It is supposed to find you the quickest way to the destination without incurring a penalty. Parking lot penalties are supposed to be incurred when the route leaves a parking lot and goes back onto a street. I didn’t examine every segment in your proposed route, but I don’t see your route touching any streets after it enters the parking lot. If you look back at the route in my original post, it crosses Henry St between the GO lot and the Iroquois Arena lot, so it should incur a penalty.
@hmarian: It has been over a month – any update from the Dev Team on this? I know they are quite busy all the time, just checking in to ensure this doesn’t fall off the agenda completely.
FYI, the last time I drove this route was April 9, and the problem still exists (no change with latest version of the app).
Thanks,
Roy.