Street Abbreviation poll

Which street abbreviation standard would you prefer?

  • Transition towards the AS/NZS 4819 Standard and add exceptions if required by vote
  • Prefer other standards/methods
0 voters

Hi all

Waze has stated that each community should decided on its own guidelines for mapping.

The has been much discussion on street abbreviations for Australia.

https://www.waze.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=156385&start=90

The are many options so I will start with a simple poll

While I’ve voted for the first option, I’d add that I vote in advance to support any exceptions needed to not break TTS for already-mapped roads, particularly all of the deprecated options currently listed on the proposed list.

(Note: I’ve updated that list slightly: on the “to be decided” list where we had a couple of options listed, I’ve preferred Glomp’s choice over IP Australia.)

Looks great. Only question I have is what is the story with Motorway. Shouldn’t it be in the first table?

One thing I forgot to mention about AS/NZS 4819 in its purist form is the abbreviations are limited to about 50 of the most commonly used abbreviations. After that everything is not abbreviated.

The list for NZ is even shorter.

But its up to you guys what you want to do.

From my understanding…

There is a default abbreviation list that can’t be turned off

So if Australia decides to use “Av” instead of “Ave”, “Ave” will still work as an abbreviation

e.g. everything that works now will still work regardless of any changes.

“Av” will need to be added to the google sheet to work

Are there only 6 editors in Oz that care about roading standards.

To be fair there are only about 3 in NZ

I will be honest. I really do not understand the question.

When you label a street what abbreviation do you use?

e.g.

If you use the US Postal service as a source see how many types of abbreviations one could use for AVENUE

http://pe.usps.gov/text/pub28/28apc_002.htm

Why should the street type in the Waze database be abbreviated at all? It makes no sense to have a contraction in the actual stored data.

Oh dear…

I actually personally don’t disagree but I sense no support for this concept in the Australia waze community. (my background is openstreetmap)

Here in Qld, street signs for Avenue are Ave, so that is what is used and recognised by waze.

I guess part of the reason is that for some ‘endings’, there can be different spellings for the same word. Also, as it stands, waze is programmed to pick up a certain abbreviation in the TTS. If you use Ter for Terrace, waze will say Ter, as in Macgregor Ter, when the street name is actually Macgregor Terrace. If you use the correct abbreviation of Tce, then waze recognises this, and says Macgregor Terrace.

I believe there is also another factor, although possibly minor. The more letters and words that are included, the more bandwidth that is required at each updated, and so using abbreviations keeps this to a minimum. This helps reduce the data that all wazers chew through when using waze.

I have seen street signs that say Av and also Ave in WA. Street signs are installed by local councils, it’s up to those councils to decide what they put on them.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Can you show us examples

I’ll be interested how google maps, bing maps etc handle this.

My guess is a profession mapping services standardize the abbreviations?

Look at this example

The street sign says “Elstree Av” but google maps says “Elstree Ave”

We know the real name is “Elstree Avenue” and I don’t think it really matters what abbreviation (in relationship to the sign) we use but I think it should be standardized like a professional mapping service.

https://goo.gl/maps/Vc8ifaT4tqy

Isn’t that what we’ve done by having the wiki page as reference? When you look at town planning sites their abbreviation for Avenue is Av, I think it doesn’t matter that much. Waze TTS should be able to handle both, it’s not like either could be mistaken for something else.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

And this is concentrating on a pretty simple example, Ave or Av. But the point is- there are more complex examples- Motorway, Terrace, Court, Circuit etc.

Court could be fully written, but is abbreviated. Circuit is also abbreviated. Terrace, if abbreviated to Ter is pronounced Ter- which is incorrect, as I mentioned before.

And then there is Motorway.

So I think we should move off Avenue and move back to the actual discussion.

I this case this would happen automatically

We can not turn off the TTS abbreviation “Ave” but we can control how we label the streets

We can add “Av” to the custom list.

The question has been what do we add to the custom list. (we can’t change the default list)

Yep agreed. Can everyone just vote if they are happy with the proposed list so we can move this along. All we are looking to agree on is what the abbreviations are moving forward. What is in the map currently will still be supported. As I mentioned earlier I am happy although I did have a question about why Motorway isnt in the first table?

I was trying to search for Douglas Ave in Yokine the other day and Waze wouldn’t show it in the search results unless I specified the correct abbreviation on record in WME. (“Av”)