Best way to avoid inconvenient routing

Hey folks,

Looking for some advice regarding routing on my street. Permalink
I live on Sycamore Ave, and when using Waze, routing currently routes me onto the road, then says to turn right, then right again (Segments selected in the permalink) instead of continuing onto the main part of Sycamore (which is the ideal route).
You can drive down both parts, but the segment that I have now temporarily converted to a “private road”, is very thin (just wide enough for a car to drive down) with residential parking spaces on the left.
Changing to a “private road” has corrected the problem in terms of routing, but wasn’t sure if this is the best solution, or if there was a better solution out there. (Don’t think parking lot road is suitable).

Any suggestions or advice is appreciated.

I believe after a good few journeys waze would work out that your route is the quicker way, but what you have done or a Parking Lot Road stops waze routing through it so job done :slight_smile:

I’ll leave it as a private road then.
Thanks, Ian. :slight_smile:

There is little difference to how Waze routes when it comes to Private Roads & Parking Lots Roads… it will route into both, but routing out of either will generate a big penalty so both are useful for stopping through routing.

As a personal rule I tend to use PLRs when the road is publically accessible and Private when there is a gate or it physically states that it is private.

It is unlikely that Waze would ‘learn’ the quicker route between these two options as they are close enough together and short enough that by the time Waze has realised you have taken the route away from the suggested route you have already passed the section and back on the suggested route. It will then likely assign your speed data to the wrong segment :?

With the road having dedicated parking spots, maybe a parking road might be more suitable.

I think you will find the reason for this is because the ‘main’ road has an extra segment, given two routes of the same length Waze will probably select the one with the fewest segments.

My advice is to delete this segment which in any case looks like it has the wrong city and state attached to it :shock: .

I assume the city and state should be Oldham, Oldham and not New Moston, Manchester, having those details wrong will cause other problems.

Once you have deleted the segment then you will need to put an extra node in your ‘private’ road and make sure you have all the turn restrictions set correctly.

Thanks for that Andy. I’ve removed the segment (so that the main route is one segment), and changed the private road back to a standard street (unless you think it should stay as a private/parking lot road), but split it into 2 segments. I’ll test this after the next tile update (now that I get notifications of these).

I’ve also updated the street info so that it correctly states “Sycamore Ave, Chadderton, Oldham”. This was the next thing on my list for roads at rank 1 in my area, as some street are incorrectly labelled as “New Moston, Manchester” or “Oldham, Oldham”.

I’d be inclined to leave it as a street, since it is a public road with no access restrictions. Just drive along it very slowly. Since it is unlikely that any other Wazer will be using it, Waze will learn it’s speed from your journeys only, and this should soon lead to it switching to your preferred route (as long as you drive at a reasonable speed when you go the better way).

I couldn’t possibly suggest this, but you could “help” this process by walking up and down the street with Waze running. :lol:

:lol: :lol: :lol:
We shall see what happens!

Thanks everyone for there help. I will test as soon as the tile update goes live (since I now use Waze for EVERY journey).

You may want to get a copy of WME Color Highlights which amongst other things will highlight streets that are part of a particular city, it makes the job much easier. At the moment it is showing all the streets the other side of Yew Tree School as part of Oldham, I assume these should also be part of Chadderton, either that or a load of the main roads are wrong. It’s almost a never ending job. :lol:

Wow, great script. Will make that job so much easier. Thanks. :slight_smile:

If you doing Speed Limits this will help as well :slight_smile:

Thanks for the tip. I’m trying not to do lots of mini edits, as I know this boosts your edit count, and don’t want to get to level 2 unfairly. But I will keep your tips in mind. :slight_smile:

If you changing the city name and speed limit its one edit so nothing to worry about. It counts per segment not what you do with it. Also i found checking on street view of speed limit signs was a great way to confirm layouts as well and restrictions. Still amazed what i find :slight_smile:

Well, routing is still wrong, even after the 1 segment/2 segment switch. Trying to update the speed data is not going to work properly either. I think because the roads are so close together, Waze has an issue trying to figure out which part of the road I am on (shows on the route even if i don’t follow it). Its also difficult to follow Wazes route when going home as the road is usually blocked, or has oncoming traffic.
I’ve resorted to changing the road to a “parking road” for now, as the road is very narrow, and people only use it when parking up, or if there is oncoming traffic on the main part.