UR advice please

Could a senior editor offer some advice on this UR please?

Should things stay as they are or should the private road be changed to a normal road?

Richard

https://www.waze.com/editor/?env=row&lon=-0.02564&lat=51.50654&layers=4069&zoom=5&segments=271175258

This is all down to the how Waze displays parking and private roads on the client.

Some colour schemes barely show them at all. The attached screenshot is from the Waze 4.0.1 iOS map editors scheme. This is the BEST I could find, in other schemes you can barely see it is there.

Therefore the comment by the editor is fair, should we change the map to fix a shortcoming of the client? That is debatable.

I was about to would propose the opposite, change all the roads within the private area to private but I see that is now not recommended, which is a pity as it would have displayed better ie all the private roads would show up the same rather than it looking like there is a break in the road.

However I don’t think the reporter is worried about how the map is displayed, they are more concerned about the incorrect routing.

I think the first thing you should do here is check with the reporter exactly what destination they have entered in Waze, armed with that information you can try some test routing in Live Maps, I have tried a few destinations but have been unable to get it to fail. It might be a time / traffic problem, I’m testing on a Sunday morning, you may need to test at the same time the reporter had problems.

One thing that does strike me as incorrect in the map is that the entrance causing problems is a two way road and marked as private, the other two entrances are dual carriageways with only the inbound segment marked as private. This should mean that the two way road is never used for exiting Canary Wharf (because it will mean you have to go over a private road) however I have not been able to get it to fail. You have to be very careful when mapping private installations that you don’t add a penalty on exit.

But after waffling on for ages :lol: I have just spotted the reason it is failing :smiley: and that is because there is another private segment at the entrance to the ramp (there is also one on the southern approach) so the fix is simple, change the segment on West India Ave to street. That will solve the routing issue and clear up the map display in one go. It always pays to look further afield - I was doing my test routing from the ramp so missed this extra segment.

Back to my original suggestion, does anyone know why we shouldn’t map the entire area as private, it would make the map display better and should prevent simple editing mistakes from breaking routing?

Good spot … was too early in the morning for me!

I agree that the colour schemes make this look very poor in the client. Either:

  1. A very short way finder segment as the private road.

  2. Something like the CCZ entrances but with no restrictions, just private going inwards and street going outwards.

  3. All private.

  4. works best, I already use something similar on military installations such as RAF Waddington (though this gate is not open 24/7 so has time restrictions too).

Here are the Conditions of Access to the estate Conditions.jpg

Since I started a new thread :wink:

Also another Problem here which thankfully I am not to worried about. But I have a company I delver to on Westferry Circus which is the roundabout here. Now there address is 1 Westferry Circus. Now I can’t add this building number since we don’t name Roundabouts.

Any suggestions on how to do this?

What about just adding a place point? Make sure it is closest to Westferry Circus on the map otherwise you may get directed to the underground (outer) roundabout.

I don’t suppose the place point has to be right by the door of the building, rather it should be just next to the nearest point on Westferry Circus.

Chris, Andy & Dave, Thank you very much for your help and input on this, without you, i’d still be scratching my head.

Sorry for the delay in getting back to you and working on the fix, My wife’s not been too well for the past week, so i’ve not been here.

Thank you all

Richard