Regarding "Cities" Part II - New Zealand

Re:Post as per personal conversation

I’ve been thinking about this post, but it a big topic and I’ve been procrastinating

Much has changed with Waze since I started…

The Cities field has always been controversial.

To add to the complexity the NZ address system is different to many parts of the world.

e.g

83 Dundale Ave Blockhouse Bay Auckland 0600

30 Pitt St Parramatta NSW 2150

Notice is Australia they don’t use the city “Sydney” anywhere in the address. Strange I know but I suspect that this is the case in many parts of the world?

The question is do we use the “suburb” or “city” in the city field?

In the beginning people used 3 methods

  • Auckland
  • Blockhouse Bay
  • Blockhouse Bay, Auckland

The last is the most correct but looks awful on the Waze client.

In the beginning to find a street address information could only be found in waze. But now the address can be found by information in Google maps, so the address is now not so important.

To make doubly sure of the correct address was found we added the full address to the alt field

Now that we have done this changing the city field to Auckland is not such a big deal.

Then the question is why?

To make the map look good when you zoom out on the client.

Waze has this funny system that bigger city area polygons take preference when zooming out

Because rural areas had bigger land mass therefore they would show up before Auckland as an example

I had more stuff to say but this will do for now…

Personally,
I think “city” in the “city” field would tidy up the map.
All the info for the address is contained in the secondary field now, and would remove the need for brackets. Like Lincoln (Auk) & Lincoln (Can)

I agree

The other things I didn’t talk about was

  • Copyright
  • No offical suburbs for NZ
  • County Field

I understand the UK have a county field

I’ve requested that field for NZ but no reply yet

“No official suburbs” will be tough with the urban sprawl happening at present!

I mean legislative suburbs.

map makers can make there own boundaries

e.g. NZ post is different to NZ Fire which is different to NZ electoral address

I do just like having the city as Auckland, much cleaner looking in the client and on the site.

Where can you see it updated?

When the server updates I guess?

Any updates on this? Any objections?

  • Auckland

Gonna start the changeover, seems no objections.